Keyword Search:
text size: A | A | A
Misdiagnosis May Have Been Death Sentence for District Man
   posted 10:29 pm Wed December 03, 2008
ABC 7 News - Misdiagnosis May Have Been Death Sentence for District Man
  ABC 7 News - Share Misdiagnosis May Have Been Death Sentence for District Man  ABC 7 News - Print Misdiagnosis May Have Been Death Sentence for District Man  ABC 7 News - Email Misdiagnosis May Have Been Death Sentence for District Man  ABC 7 News - RSS Feeds  ABC 7 News - Send Misdiagnosis May Have Been Death Sentence for District Man via Instant Messager
ABC 7 News - Share This Article
Stay on top of breaking news! Sign up for ABC 7 News e-mail alerts.
Your Email:  
WASHINGTON - Authorities are currently investigating whether a District man's sudden death could have been averted if Emergency Medical Services personnel had not misdiagnosed his condition as mere acid reflux.

According to Lolitha Givens, mother of 39-year-old Ed Givens, he was a healthy father of two teenage boys with no history of heart trouble or breathing problems. His general good health was one reason why his complaints of chest pain and shortness of breath Tuesday night concerned her. Givens had eaten a hamburger earlier in the day and Lolitha Givens said that's why at first they thought it was acid reflux.

Givens called an ambulance, and EMS personnel examined Givens. After hearing his symptoms, they diagnosed him with acid reflux and suggested an antacid, according to Ed's brother.

Mere hours later, Givens was dead.

"To wake up and find him dead on the floor is breathtaking, just breathtaking," said Lolitha Givens. "The thing that gets me is the ambulance refused to take him. They convinced us he was OK."

"It's like someone has taken a part of my heart," said Lolitha Givens. "It's hard," she said. "I don't have an answer to my son's death."

As extended family members arrived at the Givens home to comfort one another, they expressed outrage that Ed Givens was not taken to the hospital, even as a precaution.

"They came, they looked at him, they left him and six hours later he's dead," said Sabrina Givens, Ed's cousin.

"I feel they could have done better," said Anthony Givens, Ed's brother. "They should have took him at his word and took him to the hospital to make sure everything was OK."

"And if it played out correctly like I think the proper protocol would have proven than we would have our nephew here today," said the victim's uncle, Anthony Givens Sr. "All of us will die at some point, but to die prematurely because of someone else's mistake is uncalled for."

"I should have made them take him, I should made them," said Lolitha Givens. "But I listened to them, I listened to them, I listened to them, I shouldn't have listened."

On Wednesday, ABC 7/NewsChannel 8 learned the department launched a full scale investigation to determine if personnel mishandled Givens' care.

A number of sources familiar with the standing operating procedure said that based on the victim's history and symptoms, he should've been taken to the hospital.

After a series of missteps by D.C. paramedics when New York times journalist David Rosenbaum was murdered, the city has been aggressively trying to improve emergency services.

"If there was a misstep made, we'll get that information out. The chief has been very good at holding people accountable and being transparent," said D.C. Mayor Adrian Fenty.

Givens' cause of death in the case will be determined by the medical examiner after an autopsy.

Email To A Friend  Email This Article

Follow ABC 7 News on Twitter

How To Save Energy Around Your Home? Click Here
ABC 7 Talkback: Misdiagnosis May Have Been Death Sentence for District Man
keepitreal
Firstly I am sorry for the loss of their loved one. Something so tragic should not happen to someone so young.

I want everyone out there to know that emt's at any level are NOT doctors and do not have the equipment to give a diagnosis on the scene. It is simply not possible. EMTs are highly skilled professionals that do the best they can at life saving intervention until care can be transferred to doctors that can run tests and do labwork.

EMTs that are properly trained should ALWAYS  suggest coming with them to the hospital , especially in an occurance like this. If the EMTs flatly refused to transport this patient that is definitely wrong and a breach of protocol. I just want people to know YOU know your body best and if you feel you need to go to the hospital or should seek treatment GO TO THE HOSPITAL.

Once again EMTs are not doctors and SHOULD NOT BE GIVING ANY KIND OF DIAGNOSIS ON SCENE. Either insist emts transport you or find alternate transportation to the hospital if they refuse to take you (which they NEVER should do)

You need to be a registered member of
ABC 7 News to leave comments on news stories.
Not a member yet? Click Here to sign up.
Username or Email Address
Password
Please leave your comments below:
Messages that harass, abuse or threaten other members; have obscene or otherwise objectionable content; have spam, commercial or advertising content or inappropriate links may be removed and may result in the loss of your posting privileges. Please do not post any private information unless you want it to be available publicly. Never assume that you are completely anonymous and cannot be identified by your posts.
TM & © WJLA/NewsChannel 8, a division of Allbritton Communications Company
Please read our Privacy Policy. By using this site, you accept our Terms of Service.
Children's Television | EEO Reports | DTV Consumer Education Reports
WJLA adheres to the ICRA RATING SYSTEM
  {ts '2008-12-05 06:53:52'}